Three Scottish Badges

[jfenzy1]

Hello all,
Could I get a verdict on these 3 Scottish badges please?
Unsure as to wether the lugs make the grade or not. I would value a few opinions.
Regards,
Jim.

[Home Guard]

I'm not the expert, but they all look good to me. I am sure those more knowledgeable will confirm or advise other wise.

Terry

[cbuehler]

The only one I am completely comfortable with is the Seaforth, a later WW2 era badge. The Gordon may be ok, but the lugs are a bit iffy.
The QC KOSB is bad in my opinion.

CB

[jfenzy1]

Thanks for your input guys. Its the white metal lugs that raised my suspicion with the Seaforth.
Jim