Newfoundland Badge for review - British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

irish · #1 28-01-17, 07:06 PM

Having looked at a number of pieces posted I still cannot decide if this one is good or a duffer. Am having some doubt.

The finish appears to gilt, Measure 34mm x 28mm, any and all opinions are much welcomed

thanks
Jack

Bill A · #2 28-01-17, 09:41 PM

Quality of the image isn't the best, but from what I can see it looks ok.

irish · #3 28-01-17, 10:03 PM

Thanks Bill, my phone camera is not the best.
Jack

whizzbang · #4 29-01-17, 01:36 AM

Hi - is the badge stamped or cast? The image makes it look cast - if so, I'd say it's not a good one, Cheers, Ian.

irish · #5 29-01-17, 04:00 AM

Let me take a better photo. It looks stamped but not sure.
Jack

magpie · #6 29-01-17, 07:11 AM

You can see it's clearly a cast badge and not die stamped.

irish · #7 29-01-17, 01:22 PM

Ok thanks. Cast, so a duffer.

NFLDREGT · #8 31-01-17, 02:57 AM

Picture makes it look horrible especially at the bottom and the lugs just bad. I don't think a bad picture could make one look that much off. I wouldn't touch this one if it were up for auction.

Regards

Don