Commando badges

[Alex Rice]

Hi All
Can I have some opinions on these two please? The first one (with both lugs) I'm fairly sure is a fake but would like confirmation before I ditch it. The second one (missing a lug) is a theatre made badge and slightly bigger. Were these made in Egypt or somewhere like that during the war?
Any advice appreciated, thanks in advance.
Cheers,
Alex

Hi Alex
yes the 1st is a copy the lugs twisted that the give away and the other is ok

peter

[Alex Rice]

Hi Peter
Thanks very much, that's great. I was expecting them both to be duds.
Cheers,
Alex

[tedwardland]

I 2nd that, i picked one up a few weeks back with the same lug missing, lovely pieces.