Argyll & Sutherland Opinions Welcome

[Neil s]

Don't think I have seen a Badge with so much variation
IMG_20210213_123032.jpgIMG_20210213_123042.jpgIMG_20210213_123116.jpgIMG_20210213_123126.jpgIMG_20210213_123149.jpgIMG_20210213_123200.jpgIMG_20210213_123226.jpgIMG_20210213_123236.jpg

IMG_20210213_123300.jpgIMG_20210213_181051.jpgIMG_20210213_123328.jpgIMG_20210213_123335.jpgIMG_20210213_123406.jpgIMG_20210213_123413.jpg

[Neil s]

Second A/A
IMG_20210213_123432.jpgIMG_20210213_123440.jpgIMG_20210213_123626.jpgIMG_20210213_123633.jpg

Not a fan of this badge and why cut the lugs off
IMG_20210213_123527.jpgIMG_20210213_123537.jpg

Collars
IMG_20210213_125957.jpgIMG_20210213_130030.jpg

Dumbarton RV / VB
IMG_20210213_130121.jpgIMG_20210213_130136.jpg

Titles
IMG_20210213_130204.jpgIMG_20210213_130217.jpg

[Alex Rice]

The first badge may be original but it looks like somebody took a drill or dremel to it to do the voiding? That does not look like it was voided at manufacture, pretty rough looking.
Cheers,
Alex

[Neil s]

Hi Alex
I think the voiding is pre dremel and looks as if it's punched out from the front

[dubaiguy]

Here's the 'Martin Marsh' fake. The same die was used with and without various banners attached.

[dubaiguy]

Perhaps this image illustrates the similarities better.

[cbuehler]

The basic design of this badge was worn for so long that a seeming myriad of small variations exist.
The volunteer badges to this regiment seem to be a near impossibility; not to mention most other regiments I suppose. I have been so jaded as to just skip by every most every one I see.
That home made voided badge is interesting, albeit not correct of course.
A nice lot though!

CB

[Neil s]

Plastic
IMG_20210725_185624.jpgIMG_20210725_185635.jpg