202nd Edmonton Sportsmens' Collars..opinions pls

[Pink]

Have 2 different collars for the 202nd...would like opinions...first my thoughts and please let me know if I am on the right track...am only gong by my Charltons Book..
the collar with the lugs IMO is a Tiptaft...clues...wide feet on the lugs, narrower Rifle butts and ever so slightly larger type in the ribbons...the other collar IMO is a Jackson....it was converted from north/south lugs to east/west pin profile, has wider rifle butt design and smaller type in the legends...
Have has conversations with an individual who is adamant that only Jackson made these for the 202nd...

Opinions please....

[whizzbang]

Hi Pink,

The lugs on the first badge look like Tiptaft, I think you are right.

Cheers, Ian.

[Pink]

Thank you Ian...appreciate the reply...

Cheers