Commando badge?

[Bill A]

Is this a good example? I suspect not.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Orig-WW2-Ca...IAAOSwVcZcCZAg

[Roy]

Not correct at all in my opinion.

Cheers,

Roy

[fougasse1940]

Why would an incomplete example like this merit the good or no good test?
Seller seems to turn up regularly in threads like this, that ought to be a sign?

Rgds, Thomas

[Bill A]

Hi Thomas, I quess that IS the point. These are out of my area of expertise, just wanted some further opinions.

[Mike B]

Not as bad as some fakes, would need better image of remaining lug. The definitive lug for ME Cdo in flat metal, bent over, ends set into casting.
I prefer cast examples with 'spattering' to reverse, and am wary of other variants unless attributed (I do have a few variants though).
Mike
PS - The badge was issued to 50, 51 and 52 ME Cdo - but found its way to other unit headdress too, the later ME Commando included.