Colouring of WW1 photos

[Jeff Mc William]

Hi all
Concerning this latest "craze" of colouring WW1 photos, I wonder what other members think of this ?
Without doubt, the technology and the skill and patience of the creators is superb .. but does there not have to be a certain amount of knowledge and research have to be involved as well as the desire to "update" the presentation of these images ?
I am looking at one prize example at the moment ; its shows a crowd scene on Armistice Day 1918 and someone is waving a White Ensign with a blue St.George's Cross which make me wonder how many other mistakes have been made. Personally I think nothing can beat the original B&W images which, in themselves convey a clearer air of poignance and authenticity than those that have been "meddled with". Any other thoughts ? Jeff