91 CEF (Elgin Overseas)

[WJ Miller]

I am starting to think about putting together a collection of Elgin Regiment items. I see that currently there are two badges for the 91st Bn CEF on ebay. However, in looking at these (one is labeled an officer's variety) and in recalling one I saw C. Brooker selling about 6 weeks ago, they seem to be of a rather lacklustre manufacture. Both the finish and strike in these examples is weak.

I am wondering if this is as good as this particular badge gets or should I keep my eye out for better examples/diff. makers??