Chaplain badges

[stef]

Hi,

From an older collection I bought a few months ago, mainly consisting of original cloth badges were also approximately 50 cap badges, they were all framed but because I have learnt there are a lot of restrikes out there I would like to check most here first.

Chaplain badge, marker marked Scully LTD Montreal.

Jewish Chaplain badge, no maker.

[arrestingu]

Hi
The first looks fine ,the flat back to my eye looks wrong
Cheers
Steve

[stef]

I did some further searching into the flat back badge.
It seems most being offered as original have a half hollow circle on the back. But there is not much information available online.

Someone else with an opinion or evidence that it is fake?

[Home Guard]

My chaplain badge has the indented circle in the back, but has blades instead of lugs. Would that still be correct for a real one? Thanks,

Terry