Hi Doug, it wouldn't surprise me if these badges were being reprod - no rant, I promise
I believe Scully is still in business, although they may contract out thier badge making to someone else (if anyone knows, let US know as well). If this the case then I'm sure they would like to know thier products are being counterfited.
Re the badge in question, I guess the real test would be to test it for silver content, if it is SS all the way though and marked so then it is probably a good one. We could also compare the size and weights of our badges and see it they are fairly close in size and weight.
Greg