I would advocate an "all or none" policy with regards to listing dealers.
With the exception of dealers that openly only sell reproduction, I think that any online dealer should be listed. Individual badges can be discussed...and opinions on sellers can be discussed via PM.
Having read this, and other threads, I find myself agreeing with some comments on dealers, and completely disagreeing with others. This is my OPINION and based on my own dealings (in a very narrow field of collecting) with these sellers.
I feel a list based solely on recommendations is dangerous...members that have differing (ie. negative) views/experiences are less likely to voice these concerns publicly.
My 2 cents worth.
|