John
Fantastic.
I do wonder whether the 1st VB wore the same badges with a 1st numeral or whether it had no additional scrolls because it was the 1st? There was precedence for this in other VBs.
Another suggestion is that the scrolless badges were worn by the 3rd Vb which was raised in 1900.
More research to do.
Just when I thought I was uncertain enough I found this post1905 militia officer's badge - with SA honours in the centre!
http://www.the-saleroom.com/en-gb/au...6-a42500036860