Gordon Highlanders and Grenadier Guards Opinions Please
 

Opinions please on these two badges.

My concerns are as follows:-

Gordon Highlanders has been struck using a broken die as is shown in picture 2 resulting in a blank scroll end. Is this a known defect on good badges?

Grenadier Guards has a lightweight tapered slider. Is this correct. Got to say it looks better in the picture than it looks in hand.

Thoughts please

Eric

The Grenadier Guards grenade is ok.
Andy

Gordon Highlanders and Grenadier Guards Opinions Please
 

Thanks for that Andy, much appreciated.

Any comments out there on the Gordons?

Eric

I have the same badge. As far as I'm concerned, a good one, until any contrary evidence comes to light. One from the gallery; (I'm sure there's others). https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/fo...ctureid=107394 Mike

Thanks for taking the time to comment Mike.

So a good one then, excellent.

Eric