British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Cavalry, Yeomanry, Tank/RAC Badges (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Lincolnshire Yeomanry (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=11353)

Malcolm Davey 29-01-08 03:58 PM

Lancashire Hussars
 
Hi Chaps
I have two of these badges and would like to know if one or both are genuine or not, both have lugs in different positions, could anyone post a picture of a genuine one for comparision, or know what to look for.

I can Scan each badge on it's own if you need bigger pictures.

Cheers
Malc

Peter Brydon 29-01-08 06:46 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Another minefield, both the Lancashire Hussars Yeomanry and Imperial Yeomanry examples have been well and truly copied. I am attaching a photo of my Lancashire Hussars items but with the only comment that you should be particularly suspicious of white metal examples

P.B.

Alan O 30-01-08 08:17 PM

I am afraid that this badge has been so widely faked it is indeed a minefield. Bearing in mind the Regt went artillery in 1920 and adopted RA badges and as far as I know did not readopt the old ones, this should be one of the scarcest Yeomanry badges going. Likewise the Lincolnshire Yeomanry were disbanded in 1920 and are also as common as these ones indicated huge amounts of faking.

As far as your 2 go the darker one looks far better to me. The other one is too yellow and new to have any chance of being a 90 year old badge. I have a slidered version which I bought from a trustworthy (sic) dealer. I will try and get a good photo but the copy dies are exact as far as I can see to any reference picture or example I have seen. Unfortnately while there is an IY example in Wilkinson's book, I cannot see where the lugs are place. I wold not be surprised if they were even N-S vertical!

Alan

Peter Brydon 31-01-08 07:07 PM

Alan,
You are correct ,but if I might add a couple of points, according to Norman Lichfield " The Territorial Artilllery" up untill 1940 the successor unit wore the Lancashire Huusars white metal rose collar on the service dress tunic, and after the war an embroidered arm badge was authorised for wear on the on battleddress blouses. ( see the illustration of my L.H. items ).
P.B.

Alan O 31-01-08 08:33 PM

2 Attachment(s)
head above parapet time! The front and back of my Lancashire Hussars.

Alan

Alan O 31-01-08 09:22 PM

1 Attachment(s)
For comparison a badge with the cut out end of wreath and the JRGaunt.London mark on the slider seen on a a well known ebay sellers merchandise.

Alan

Keith Blakeman 31-01-08 09:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Owen (Post 2489)
While I am putting my head above the parapet I thought I would show this Lincolnshire Hussars badge - half a dozen on ebay every week. However the reason I like this one (apart from the colour, deep strike and style of long tapering slider) is that it matches the one shown in Wilkinson's Book. Particularly the top of the wreath on each side is continuous unlike the cut out version seen on the fakes.

Thoughts?

Alan

I like this badge and apart from Wilkinson's and Alan's, these are the only examples I've seen like this. It's one I won't hesitate to buy should it come up.

Peter Brydon 01-02-08 07:06 AM

Just as a matter of interest and to reinforce the point about how scarce cap badges to this regiment should be, it took me some considerable time to find any Lancashire Hussar buttons and in fact apart from the 2 large and 2 small ones which I have managed to acquire, I think have only ever seen one,possibly two others for sale in many many years.
P.B.

Peter Brydon 01-02-08 07:35 AM

1 Attachment(s)
I have just remembered this picture I have of a Lancashire Hussars officers full dress cap/badge.The mess dress collars were similar but there was a space between the crown and the rose.

P.B.

Rockape 01-02-08 09:25 AM

Alan and Keith,

I like the badge shown and agree it looks good.

Garry

Alan O 01-02-08 04:22 PM

Garry,

You are quite right - there may have been 2 makers and 2 dies. But in the same way there may have been more than one fake die amde -each with a different crown!

I only believe mine is right as I have never seen another example except for the one in Wilkinsons book which is a good guide as the collection was mostly collected pre -restrike. This would suggest a rarity of a WW1 era Yeomanry unit should have. Yours may be fine but that type has been so widely faked I could not say for certain. The badge is not in K&K Vol 2 when I looked yesterday. Vol 1 may show the cut out ended version but I cannot remember for certain as I am away from my books this week.

Alan

Chrisr 07-02-08 07:09 AM

2 Attachment(s)
I have one that is much the same as Garry's. It is much darker than the photographs show - more of a dark chocolate colour, very solid, in fact unable to bend in any way, but unfortunately the lugs have been poorly repaired with epoxy. It has been in my collection for many years and I assumed it to be the genuine article.

Cheers
Chris

Keith Blakeman 19-02-08 09:59 PM

3 Attachment(s)
Got one at last! Closer inspection reveals that the wreath isn't continuous to the upper corners, these are in fact ribbon tails. The wreath ends short and the small amount in between the last leaf and ribbon out to be cut out to accentuate the ribbon. Therefore I don't think that it's variation, more a factory error by one or more maker.

Malcolm Davey 12-03-08 08:48 PM

The difference in the centre of the rose and the shape of the lugs with brazing in the middle and they are north and south, the fact it came from the same collection as the KVF,4th Vol Cheshire, I believe I now have a genuine Lancashire Hussars.
I refer to the badge on the Right.

Cheers
Malc

jim a 13-05-09 11:37 PM

Lincolnshire Yeomanry
 
Condition of the badge is not the greatest due to the verdigis that's on the back and creeping out to the front. Besides that I'm wondering about any issues RE: restrike problems... thanks http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v2.../badges063.jpg


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:33 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.