British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Cavalry, Yeomanry, Tank/RAC Badges (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   24th Lancers badge...help info required. (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=74644)

BHC1944 22-07-19 08:56 AM

24th Lancers badge...help info required.
 
3 Attachment(s)
Hello guys,

If someone could please help me with this 24th lancers badge, is it an original ww2 badge ? thank you. Paul.


Attachment 209906

Attachment 209907

Attachment 209908

Alan O 22-07-19 09:31 AM

Unfortunately these badges were widely restruck in the 1970s. Unlike the 26th Hussars where the die used had noticeable flaws compared to the original badges, the 24th lancers badges are nigh on impossible to differentiate.

However I would prefer to see a slider on this badge rather than lugs.

BHC1944 22-07-19 11:30 AM

Hello Alan,

Thank you for help and information much its appreciated. :)

I have only recently been getting interested in British badges so my knowledge is some what limited but what type of badge would be used on a WW2 British beret ? ...lugs or slider ? , my thought that slider was WW1 time frame or there about's.

Alan O 22-07-19 02:06 PM

The use of sliders remained the norm for most cap badges in WW2 even for units wearing berets.

The majority of regts wore side caps then GS caps.

Whilst the RAC, Para and RTR all wore lugged badges on their berets, many regiments, including the war- raised cavalry ones, retained sliders. The 22nd Dragoons, 26th 25th Dragoons and the 23rd Hussars all wore badges with sliders.

Alan

Alan O 22-07-19 03:22 PM

I believe that both Firmin and Gaunt dies exist for this badge. The Firmin badges do come with a named slider.

The 2 dies have minor variations in the fine details.

If you search the Forum you will see examples of both lugged and slidered versions.

This is the Firmin one:

https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/fo...ctureid=105087

Frank Kelley 22-07-19 04:05 PM

I would replace that if I were you, there used to be plenty of those around, far too many, four decades ago, I should imagine they have found their way into collections, these days, they seem to command a high price.


Quote:

Originally Posted by BHC1944 (Post 484145)
Hello guys,

If someone could please help me with this 24th lancers badge, is it an original ww2 badge ? thank you. Paul.


Attachment 209906

Attachment 209907

Attachment 209908


Frank Kelley 23-07-19 03:53 PM

Ironically, the only RAC and RTR rankers badges I have with a WW2 provenance, to the same individual, both have sliders.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan O (Post 484156)
The use of sliders remained the norm for most cap badges in WW2 even for units wearing berets.

The majority of regts wore side caps then GS caps.

Whilst the RAC, Para and RTR all wore lugged badges on their berets, many regiments, including the war- raised cavalry ones, retained sliders. The 22nd Dragoons, 26th 25th Dragoons and the 23rd Hussars all wore badges with sliders.

Alan


Alan O 23-07-19 04:46 PM

The First pattern RAC brass RAC in wreath were slidered whilst the mailed fist are mostly found with lugs.

Marcus H 24-07-19 08:06 AM

The 24L ORs shown in this thread, I call the ‘Flange’ fake.

With other notable details aside, the most prominent tell-tale on this fake is the surplus metal adjoining the lance and circlet directly above the letter ‘R.’

Best,

Marcus

BHC1944 24-07-19 11:06 AM

Hi guys,

Thank you for the information and help, really appreciated.

If anyone has a 24th lancers badge for sale with slider, happy to pay good coin for it.;)

Cheers
Paul.

BHC1944 28-07-19 07:23 AM

2 Attachment(s)
Hi guys,

What do you think of this one...WWII or earlier ? cheers.

Attachment 210161

Attachment 210162

Marcus H 28-07-19 08:58 AM

This is an original Firmin die badge with an unmarked slider.

The 24L were raised in Dec 1940 and disbanded in Aug 1944.

Frank Kelley 28-07-19 04:51 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Interestingly, the only examples I've had with a provenance, including this one, were Firmin made.
The regiment was very badly mauled in the wretched Bocage, notwithstanding, it's members did their best with the equipment they had been given, it was, on occasion, certainly better to bale than face certain death.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Marcus H (Post 484707)
This is an original Firmin die badge with an unmarked slider.

The 24L were raised in Dec 1940 and disbanded in Aug 1944.


BHC1944 29-07-19 11:29 AM

Thanks guys appreciate the feed back on the badge. cheers.

Kind regards
Paul.

Frank Kelley 30-07-19 07:11 AM

Certainly nice badges to collect, Paul, but, you do need to be careful, it is unfortunate that the whole market place is awash with all the rubbish from the many individuals such as Messrs Green, Tenniswood and Butler, with the result so often being that fake examples are offered for the price of originals.


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:05 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.