British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Photographs of British Servicemen and Women Wearing Insignia (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=35)
-   -   Any thoughts (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=79342)

Beaker123 21-06-20 09:11 AM

Any thoughts
 
1 Attachment(s)
Any thoughts on who/what these gents are? I've considered National/Veteran Reserve, Ulster Volunteer Force, Special Constabulary (with rifles?) or maybe 'Kitchener's Army'.

Nothing on reverse to indicate location.

Many thanks

S

manchesters 21-06-20 09:39 AM

I would say they are VTC, c. 1914/15, wearing enamel lapel badges, no uniforms yet purchased.

regards

Sonofacqms 21-06-20 09:45 AM

The man in the front row on the left appears to be wearing an armband, possibly with a "V" or an inverted triangle, as Simon said VTC unit.

Rob

Beaker123 22-06-20 09:43 AM

Morning Simon and Rob,
Many thanks for your suggestions. I had pretty mich dismissed the VTC due to the absence of the GR brassard but could be.

All best

S

Alan O 22-06-20 11:22 AM

I wondered if the armband was a 'rank' as the section commander? The lapel badges do resemble the VTC ones but they look larger. i wondered if they were pre-war County Scouts? I was thinking of the pre-war National Reserve county scouts recruited to guide the army across their local areas rather than Baden Powell! Their badges were oval and that size.

Sonofacqms 22-06-20 11:50 AM

Corps of Guides
 
I did wonder whether these men could be from the Corps of Guides, I have a Suffolk and a Cambridgeshire Corps of Guides buttonhole badges, but they are both round and the badges in the photo appear to have a crown or other device.

Corps of Guides badges are scarce and I wonder whether any members have specimens in their collections that do not follow the circular type?

An interesting thread.

Rob

Alan O 22-06-20 02:04 PM

That's them - guides not scouts!

This Essex site shows that counties which is the same size as the Reserve so could be either. https://www.essexmilitarybadges.uk/home-defence-units/

Beaker123 23-06-20 11:47 AM

I'm discounting my thought that they might be Ulster Volunteer Force as photos don't show their badges as usually having crowns.

I like the suggestion of Guides but apart from the Essex example in the link supplied by Alan I don't recall seeing any others.

I've had another look under a magnifying glass but there are no details on the badges. One chap sports a metal? shield badge in his cap.

S

manchesters 23-06-20 01:11 PM

I realise I am repeating myself, but, the photo is typical of early VTC volunteers. Everything about it says to me VTC.

regards

bobbluesboy 09-07-20 06:53 PM

Could these chaps be Boer War Vets at the time of the start of WW1,Certainly looks as if one is wearing his QSA ? Another thought is could the badges they are all wearing be Special Constables ? Long Shot I know,


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:45 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.