British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Infantry (& Guards) Badges (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   The South Lancashire Regiment Badge Sizes (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=41559)

hagwalther 04-09-14 09:39 PM

The South Lancashire Regiment Badge Sizes
 
Hi Guys,

I know nothing about pre A/A cap badges but need some info on the sizes of the two GM and WM A/A South Lancashire Regiment (Prince of Wales’s Volunteers) cap badges.

I understand that two variations were manufactured being a large cap badge and a smaller beret piece.

If anyone can help with measurements both across and top to bottom I would be most grateful.

The badges in question were known in the inventory as:

Large: CB 0364 - G.M. and W.M.

Small: CB 2797 -G.M. and W.M.

Regards

Chris

Mike H 05-09-14 05:18 AM

Chris, its a genuine badge 42mm wide 32mm high smith and wright slider. It way smaller than the cap badge. Its the same size as every other S.Lancs beret bsdge.

Mike H 05-09-14 05:33 AM

Incidently the cap badge size is approx 50mm wide 40 mm high

hagwalther 05-09-14 05:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike H (Post 276213)
Chris, its a genuine badge 42mm wide 32mm high smith and wright slider. It way smaller than the cap badge. Its the same size as every other S.Lancs beret bsdge.

Hi Mike,

AS I previously said - I know nothing about pre A/A cap badges. Therefore, before I can convince myself your image is good I need to know what size the pre A/A badges were to see what we are dealing with here.

If the pre A/A badge is the same size as your A/A piece then that is an indication that your badge is good.

If you look at the work I have done you will see that I do not take much notice of anecdotal evidence and concentrate on hard facts and work from there. If you had an image of the rear of the badge then that would possibly be a good indicator. But all I am seeing so far is an obverse image on a piece of square paper and you saying that it is a good piece.

Although the slider could be an early Smith & Wright it could be, from the image you have, a 1980's knock off by a modern manufacturer. I'm looking for the early S&W slider taper on your image but even when enlarged and sharpened on PhotoShop it's not at all obvious.

I assume that you don't own the badge but just have the obverse image. If you could place this badge next to a GM and WM piece and show both sides of both images then that would probably do it but until anyone can provide this sort of info we will just have to do things the hard way.

Regards

Chris

hagwalther 05-09-14 05:48 AM

Cont.

I would also like to see dark solder on the slider and not it being the same colour as the metal used.

The reason for this is that A/A badge solder does not absorb the dye used in colouring the badges. Far all I know this badge could be made from a similar looking material to A/A as per many CCF badges. If it is a similar 'tin' material then the solder will be the same colour as the rear of the badge.

I would also like to see the maker mark to ensure it is as per period and not a modern fake. I would also want to see that the mark was applied before anodising and colour dyeing viz: without fracture lines emanating from the maker mark letters a sign that the mark was added after manufacture and would be a fake.

Mike, I hope you understand the level of investigation needed to OK what would be a very rare piece.

Regards

Chris

Mike H 05-09-14 06:33 AM

Im happy its a genuine item. I have the rear image somewhere. They certainly arent made from anything other than aa.

Alan O 07-09-14 12:53 PM

The large size is 43mm x 53 mm approx.

hagwalther 07-09-14 07:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan O (Post 276495)
The large size is 43mm x 53 mm approx.

Thanks Alan,

That's about the same as the Smith & Wright A/A version too.

Regards

Chris

Alan O 08-09-14 08:53 AM

Yes they are the same size and design.

Unfortunatley contempory photos of the South Lancs in the 1950s are not common to see what was actually worn.

Paul Spellman 08-09-14 09:21 AM

Not sure if these images help
A section of S.Lancs soldiers on exercise in Berlin 1956
Small type cap badge in use. Metal/AA ???
Paul

Paul Spellman 08-09-14 09:23 AM

Colours Parade 1956
Lge type on forage cap


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:52 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.