British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum

British & Commonwealth Military Badge Forum (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Reproductions, Restrikes, Fakes, Forgeries, and Copies (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   bone/plastic welch oddity (https://www.britishbadgeforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=90568)

JerryBB 10-08-22 07:56 PM

bone/plastic welch oddity
 
4 Attachment(s)
got this for £3 plus P&P as a BIN from ebay and it arrived today, the seller listed it as plastic but in the hand I wondered if it was horn.

I like it, a bit odd and maybe a POW badge?

Ps it was meant to be horn in the title, doh

Sonofacqms 10-08-22 08:57 PM

The Welch
 
Jerry, a nice item, with the spelling WELCH it is post Great War, possibly a trial model for WWII plastic badges?

Rob

Phil2M 10-08-22 09:03 PM

I thought of a POW badge, before I had read your post.

JerryBB 11-08-22 08:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sonofacqms (Post 585169)
Jerry, a nice item, with the spelling WELCH it is post Great War, possibly a trial model for WWII plastic badges?

Rob

My first thought was a trial piece but pow is more likely imo

dumdum 11-08-22 10:49 AM

I know from what I've been told by an ex-POW that badges were made from melted foil liners from cigarette packets and I've had at least one of these so not impossible that other materials were used.

I was even told that cap badges could be pressed into soap moulds to make them. The same informant told me that the German soap wasn't much good for anything else....

From the colour, I'm going to suggest a reformed composition from Bakelite. This may sound daft, but does it have a curious musty smell to it?

This is typical of old Bakelite light fittings, door handles and finger plates, very common at the time.

JerryBB 11-08-22 11:48 AM

Bakelite was another thought, carved from something else seems perfectly likely. In the hand it reminds me of horn, though I will try sniffing it when I get home from work

Rob Miller 11-08-22 01:30 PM

Bakelite is often made with asbestos so if its been "reformed" sniffing it may not be a good idea?

Rob

JerryBB 11-08-22 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Miller (Post 585205)
Bakelite is often made with asbestos so if its been "reformed" sniffing it may not be a good idea?

Rob

Not something I knew, thanks for the information Rob

Mike_2817 11-08-22 05:58 PM

Bakelite was a hard, infusible, and chemically resistant plastic, Bakelite was based on a chemical combination of phenol and formaldehyde (phenol-formaldehyde resin), two compounds that were derived from coal tar and wood alcohol (methanol), respectively, at that time.

Rob Miller 11-08-22 09:20 PM

Just google "bakelite asbestos" and decide for yourselves if sniffing it is a good way to live a long and pleasant life.

Rob

dumdum 11-08-22 11:15 PM

Hi

I guess I should have discussed past Bakelite sniffing with my brother the brilliant scientist!

One other POW "factoid" that I will mention is that the "kriegies" soon worked out that the more stamps on a document the better.

So they would create their forged paperwork and stamp them with rubber stamps cut from pieces of material, usually the sole of a boot, worked with razor blades or chips of broken glass.

We should not lose sight of the fact that POWs represented a vast body of talent, men who were artists, jewellers, engineers, etc. before going "into the bag".

Carving this lovely Welch badge would have been a "passion project" for someone like this.

Frank Kelley 12-08-22 06:07 AM

Can't go wrong for three quid, Jerry, very nice.


Quote:

Originally Posted by JerryBB (Post 585167)
got this for £3 plus P&P as a BIN from ebay and it arrived today, the seller listed it as plastic but in the hand I wondered if it was horn.

I like it, a bit odd and maybe a POW badge?

Ps it was meant to be horn in the title, doh


JerryBB 12-08-22 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frank Kelley (Post 585243)
Can't go wrong for three quid, Jerry, very nice.

Frank, thanks, I would have happily paid more than I have, the sellers pics were very dark and indistinct, so I did not know what I would be getting, but in the end it turned out good.

thanks to everyone who contributed, it is appreciated


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:43 AM.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.