Do these look ok?

[Broady]

Hello everyone.

I have got back into the collecting after a 20 year break. I have had these for many years and at the time i didn't realise that copies were so common.

Thoughts on if you think these might be dodgy.

The gold on the east lancashire is starting to come off.

Thanks.

Broady

[manchesters]

Broady,

First one has a plated slider, so either is totally fake or somone has plated it. Cant be sure.

The second is fake.

the third is OK

regards

[Broady]

Thanks for that Simon.

So much to learn regarding real and fakes

Broady