5th Devonshire battalion badge ?

[K.S.L.I.]

Hi here I have another badge which I am not 100% happy with any one tell me if its wrong or right
cheers PHIL

[manchesters]

Phil,

I tried to sell one I thought was OK but couldnt even get a fiver for it, because everyone believes that they are ALL fake.

The bottom line is it looks OK but I just dont know, sorry.

regards

[K.S.L.I.]

cheers mate
I understand so many fakes about
PHIL

[PJT]

Phil

I've got one just like that in my repro tin.

Weird shape crown
Thin bendy slider
Die flaw round the star on the reverse
Very sharp feel to star points
Look at the edge of the star and compare it to a standard Devons...I can't describe it but you will see what I mean

Paul

[Rob Miller]

Hi Phil

Its not the common fake, so don't throw it away, but I can't say its right either.

Sorry not much help really.

Rob

[K.S.L.I.]

Rob
cheers for your reply, this badge does have a good strong slider and the weight is good, just the poor strike on the inside bothers me a little
thanks again
PHIL