North Stafford EI good or bad
 

What do you think about this one please?

Many thanks

Martyn

Good afternoon Martyn,
It looks good to me !
Regards Chay

Many thanks Chay.

Hello Martyn,
Not a badge i would endorse, modern slider,
title font horrible! kind regards, Ricardo

Many thanks Ricardo.

Hello Martyn,
Looked ok to me :confused:

Gerard

Im not a fan either, sorry to say. The slider is all wrong.

Many thanks Gerard and Phil. 😫

Just for comparison purposes, here is mine, the slider looks quite different.

Cheers, Tim

Many thanks Tim. I do have another with a slightly longer slider than the one that I posted. These things are extremely awkward.

I would show mine, but, it has a replacement slider.

It's a minefield sometimes Martyn, but better to know than not. I am not experienced enough to pass judgement on yours, just offering up what i know to be good. A small consolation is I bet pretty much everyone here has a little (or big, lol) box of badges which turned out to be bad. I know I have.

Cheers, Tim

I got rid of all mine, once, now i have a ton more from a bad group lot i bought.

Cheers Phil and Tim. I haven't done too bad lately, better than I used to do. I try to go off age, detail front and back and construction but it seems that there are no set rules and there tend to be so many variations.

Martyn

My other one
 

Here's my other one. Does this look better?

Cheers

Martyn